0

Official event cancelled? Class of 2013 goes it alone

By DENISE MAYCOCK

Tribune Freeport Reporter

dmaycock@tribunemedia.net

FREEPORT – The class of 2013 at Jack Hayward High School attended an impromptu graduation ceremony held in Hawksbill on Tuesday, after their official event was cancelled by the school’s administration.

Determined to see their children graduate, a group of parents organised a passing out ceremony at 10am at the School for Prophetic Ministry Church for the 147 graduating seniors.

Pastor Frank Hagan and veteran educator Joseph Darville addressed the graduates, however, there was no conferring of diplomas, awards, or scholarships.

Last week, a decision was made by the school administration to cancel graduation because of reported inappropriate behaviour by some students during senior week.

The students were very disappointed with the decision and parents staged a protest at the Ministry of Education.

Mr Darville criticised parliamentary representatives on Grand Bahama for their absence.

“Not even one parliamentarian, or senator, from among the many on Grand Bahama, both government or opposition, has come to your aid or assistance. But watch carefully, for in 2017, when you are at the voting age, they will come slobbering at your door begging your vote,” he said.

He also criticised the school’s principal for withholding instruments of graduation, including diplomas, certificates, awards, final grades, transcripts, and recommendation.

Mr Darville commended the group of parents who organised the graduation ceremony.

Head girl Bianca Garland extended special thanks to parents, Mr Darville, Troy Garvey, Etienne Farquharson and community youth leader Mr Dudley Seide.

She encouraged her classmates to continue to do well.

“Today is living proof that no one or anything can or will stop us from succeeding,” she said.

Dudley Seide was very proud of his son Dominic.

“A lot of the kids were devastated because there was not going to be a ceremony, but we got together and made sure they have one,” he said.

Mr Seide said he was not so much upset that graduation was cancelled, but more becaue the Ministry of Education did not sit down with the children and explained what was going on.

“They left them to fend for themselves almost,” he said. “These students are very smart, but they made a mistake and we prayed for them and held sessions with them to let them know that there are consequences for their actions,” he said.

Patrice Mackey Symonette, the mother of graduate Lavante Symonette, believes that the school and the Ministry of Education have failed the students.

“This class can boast of being one with the highest number of honour students and it is unacceptable that the school has withheld their diplomas, certificates, and transcripts.

“That is the most hurtful part because we have students who are unable to apply for scholarships, or complete their college applications because these documents are being withheld. I feel that the MOE should look at the fact they have failed these students severely, but they will overcome,” she said.

“The minister of education and the ministry have not done their jobs, but we, the parents, have ensured that our children be rewarded for the hard work they have done,” said Mrs Symonette.

Parent Ingrid Bain said she was looking forward to her daughter Shalandra’s graduation.

“It is really a blessing. I was looking forward to this day for the very long time. She is my first child and I am very proud of her. I was very upset with how the school was trying to take this opportunity from them with no just cause, but I am glad this day is here.”

Graduate Shalandra Feaster said: “I feel good that the parents were able to make sure we had a graduation.”

Graduate Kdezha Bain, a teen mom, was very excited. “I feel good to know that I made it to the end when others didn’t. It was hard studying and having to deal with a baby at the same time, but I preserved.”

Activist Troy Garvey said he was very happy for the students and their parents.

“I felt it was unfair to cancel the graduation and today these children are leaving high school to go into real world,” he said.

“I think it was very wrong for the school principal to take such a position, she has failed as a leader.”

Mr Darville, former principal at GB Catholic High, added, “I have been a strong disciplinarian all my years as principal, and I have barred individual students when they did something very horrific from walking. But I would never have conceived… to cancel a graduation of that many young people.

“I think it was necessary that I come to their aid when I learned what was being dished out to them.

“They were being disregarded by the very people who were supposed to nurture them, care for them, and see them through at this level of their achievement.

“There was no way that we could have sent 147 students out there into the world with the stigma that was imposed upon them without any valid reason. Even after our own investigations, we have not found one iota of evidence that would be sufficient to bar a particular student form actually going through this particular ceremony much less 147 children.

“That is a pill I could not swallow and I think that any so called principal should not be called that name to impose that kind of punishment and lack of redemption that was meted to young people.”

Cecil Thompson, a former principal at Hawksbill High, said many of the parents are his former students.

“When I was serving as principal at Hawksbill High for 10 years, I could not be drunk enough or high enough to cancel graduation.

“To make a decision like this, I was always mindful, and never for a moment forgot, the people who were was paying my salary, the parents of over 2,000 students.

“ I have yet to read or hear evidence that justify the decision. There might be evidence, but I have yet to hear, or read it.

“I could not believe that 147 kids, the entire class was guilty of all the alleged things. When you get in the business of punishing the whole group, it is inherently flawed, because you can’t punish those that are innocent.”

Comments

banker 11 years, 4 months ago

Somebody has to pay the piper for undisciplined poorly socialized students. I am glad that the school took this step. It is less painful than the hard lessons that these unruly "Mamma's Darlings" will face in the real world.

Understandfacts 11 years, 4 months ago

This is absolute crap. The administration can hardly prove it was a majority of students - based on this article it is stating some. How would you people feel if the police knew a robber was in your community and arrested the whole community to sully your names? What the devil is this teaching anyone. In the real world if you don't do your job and don't adhere to the rules of the job or your binding contract, you get fired. If someone else gets fired unlawfully, if a union is in place they protest and where necessary if a lawyer or arbitrator needs to step in they do and a severance package is provided accordingly if the firm is at fault.

Banker - what are you saying?

Rontom 11 years, 4 months ago

My argument exactly. Spot on

Understandfacts 11 years, 4 months ago

This is absolute crap. The administration can hardly prove it was a majority of students - based on this article it is stating some. How would you people feel if the police knew a robber was in your community and arrested the whole community to sully your names? What the devil is this teaching anyone. In the real world if you don't do your job and don't adhere to the rules of the job or your binding contract, you get fired. If someone else gets fired unlawfully, if a union is in place they protest and where necessary if a lawyer or arbitrator needs to step in they do and a severance package is provided accordingly if the firm is at fault.

Banker -what are you saying?

Concerned 11 years, 4 months ago

In the real world, if you know of a crime and do not report it, you go to jail. WAKE UP!! I would hope that the community would tell the police who the robber was. These students knew who their fellow perpetrators were but decided to cover up for them and them come cry later.

Frosty 11 years, 4 months ago

I love how some of you can congratulate the school for cancelling graduation for maybe a moment of absent mindedness by a group of teenage Bahamians. The same Bahamian students that spent and worked hard for 12years or more if they went to kindergarten and/or had learning problems to obtain this diploma. These are the same young Bahamians who you would criticize the parents, the government and themselves about if they had not stuck out those 12+ years and ended up on the streets doing who knows what. The diploma is only half of the ending to this leg of their scholastic journey, the graduation ceremony is the other. By taking that away from them what message do you send them? "Oh because you had a momentary lapse of judgement as is common with someone your age we have decided to cancel your graduation ceremony. You know the ceremony we hold so you can stand before your friends and family and say 'look at me! I have successfully managed to get this far with your support. Thank you!'"

If the importance of a graduation ceremony is lost on you and you think the many should be punished for the few then you honestly should do some soul searching.

  • Someone who has graduated with a small minority of students who weren't allowed to attend the ceremony due to SEVERE violations of the scholastic contract of the school and was not punished along with them.

Rontom 11 years, 4 months ago

In full agreement. This is a fool's game. Luckily, the generation to come is always smarter than the present: there is no stopping the determination and progress of the youth. Shame on the bishop and sjc

ThisIsOurs 11 years, 4 months ago

That is indeed the problem, they believe they're smarter than everyone else, they have nothing to learn from an older generation. We will live in utter chaos until we accept that rules are created for everybody

2 incidents at 2 schools in the country. Very strange.

Rontom 11 years, 4 months ago

Different argument thisisours. The question on law and order, I fully support. On the question about unfairness let be clear: those students not involved in the incident are being wrongly and unjustly punished. Further, to accept the stand that All should be punished puts an asterisk to each of their diploma and really hurts their academic future. How dare one man is allowed to condemn the whole lot without indiscriminate cause, and we sit down in collective agreement over the daunting future for these student. Absolutely unjust

ThisIsOurs 11 years, 4 months ago

I didn't hear anyone say they wouldn't get a diploma or that the mark of Cain would be placed on their diploma, I understand that there will just be no "grand celebration" around the diploma giving...

Rontom 11 years, 4 months ago

I think there is an area set aside for assessment for Conduct/Behavior on one's diploma (at least it was on my sjc diploma) and that is based on all of your activities positive or negative at school

ThisIsOurs 11 years, 4 months ago

And did he say everyone would get an unfavourable assessment? Or did he say there will be no grand celebration?

Rontom 11 years, 4 months ago

Then that begs the question doesn't it?

ThisIsOurs 11 years, 4 months ago

No it doesn't, how do you know this incident had any effect on their overall conduct assessment? As far as I can see it determined whether or not their was a big splash. Their diplomas were more than likely already prepared and signed off

concernedcitizen 11 years, 4 months ago

if we go by that every student and thier parents will swear they weren,t involved ,,i commend the school ,its time for accountability in this country

ThisIsOurs 11 years, 4 months ago

I really think the parents missed the boat in this instance. They have a right to fight for whichever cause they believe in, but this could have been used as an important teaching lesson. What is the end goal for these kids? To go on to receive a higher education, to start a successful career, to be a well rounded adult, to start a family? Where will "I didn't get to go to the prom and wear the sexiest dress/most unique tuxedo I could imagine", fit in that end goal? In the next 6wks they will be at COB with the same friends, off to college or entering the work force to meet new friends and facing a more important passing out ceremony. They are babies, they are promised another 40yrs on this earth, there will be many times in their lives when they will face disappointment, times when they will not be given the prize even though they deserve it. At each of those pivotal moments they will need to put their present circumstance in perspective of their end goal, that is how they will determine which battles are worth fighting. If the parents truly believe that this ceremony/prom is a determining battle in the successful acheivement of their child's end goal, then I have nothing else to say, other than good luck, for the community's sake, please make sure you are releasing an adult in training to the Bahamas and the rest of the world.

Concerned 11 years, 4 months ago

God help us all. We need it. The "innocent" students fully knew which of their peers were involved in the incidences but they refused to identify the guilty to the school administrators. Consider the lesson in that. What happens to a nation who people see and know wrong but refuse to something about it because without their evidence, the authorities have no proof. .......and we congratulate and celebrate this... and call it determination and vision. A sad reality of our society.

concernedcitizen 11 years, 4 months ago

when a man that was principal says "he could not be drunk enough or high enough to cancel graduation" then goes on the say he was mindful of who paid his salary the 2000 parents ,that says it all ,,we all shout about crime ,kids w/ no respect etc ,,then when punishment is metted out we all wail 'its too harsh "'

Concerned 11 years, 4 months ago

That former principal deserves to get slapped and kicked in his butt for such a stupid, self-serving, self-promoting statement. Now I see how and when the degradation of students' character and behaviour began.... under his leadership as principal. Thank God he's out of the system now and not out destroying the morals of more young people due to his slack, incompetent leadership.

Sign in to comment