0

Union chief says carnival is copying rest of the Caribbean

By NICO SCAVELLA

Tribune Staff Reporter

nscavella@tribunemedia.net

BAHAMAS Public Services Union President John Pinder yesterday accused the government of copying “the rest of the Caribbean” for planning to spend $9m on promoting and introducing the Bahamas Junkanoo Carnival next year.

He also said he was willing to “bet his bottom dollar” that the government would not “break even” and make back the money it spent on promoting the Bahamas Junkanoo Carnival product.

“Vacation is supposed to be an experience,” Mr Pinder said. “People go to Orlando just for Disney World. Why we can’t have people coming to the Bahamas just for the Junkanoo experience? The only place in the world that you can experience Junkanoo is in the Bahamas.

“But we refuse to build the product. We would rather copycat what Trinidad and Barbados and the rest of the Caribbean has done, so we call it Carnival. We dare to try something on our own. We don’t dare to lose $9m trying to develop Junkanoo. No, we rather just copy something else.”

In September, Free National Movement Leader Dr Hubert Minnis called for the government to increase funding for traditional Junkanoo festivals instead of launching a new commercial cultural product.

Dr Minnis said the $9m proposed to be spent for the festival should have been used to increase the seed money and prizes offered for the Christmas and Boxing Day Junkanoo parades.

He added that the recent decision to change the festival’s name to include the word Junkanoo was a “face saving” measure to counter backlash from the cultural community.

Yesterday, Mr Pinder offered his own suggestions, saying Junkanoo should be expanded to a week-long event.

“You give them a quick 15 minute review of what Junkanoo looks like, and then you take them through the process of how a goatskin drum is made, how cowbells are made, how a costume is actually built,” he said. “And the end of the day they have to keep coming back, and at the end of their experience, you put them in a Junkanoo group and have them shaking the cowbells and beating the goatskin drums.

The first Bahamas Carnival week is scheduled for May 3-9, 2015 when four major events will be staged. A commission, chaired by former banker Paul Major, will oversee the initiative.

During an official ceremony launching the event at Pompey Square in August, Prime Minister Perry Christie expressed his optimism for the event.

Comments

ThisIsOurs 9 years, 11 months ago

Sadly this is not looking good, more should have been done to get the support of the local community, namely centring the event around Junkanoo. Right now you are banking on people who have to pay to come here to make the event a success while ignoring the captive audience of ~100,000 people.

digimagination 9 years, 11 months ago

Why not spend the money educating youth instead of investing in a parade of near-naked skin?

ThisIsOurs 9 years, 11 months ago

I completely agree, the money could and should have been used more wisely. But it's too late now for "coulda", they are targeting tourists and ignoring the Bahamian customer, I don't know who's bright idea that was

Girly 9 years, 11 months ago

We just don't realize what we have. The Bahamas Junkanoo has been voted NUMBER ONE of 10 Celebrations for 2014 among readers for USA TODAY BEATING CARNIVAL. Look it up.

DEDDIE 9 years, 11 months ago

I am not a supporter of near naked women dancing in the street, but you have to recognized the draw of the word "carnival". From purely a marketing point of view "carnival" has a greater draw than "junkanoo". It may not make sense cultural but economically which sames to be foremost in the Bahamian psyche, it wins.

ThisIsOurs 9 years, 11 months ago

There's also the argument that the majority of the proceeds from carnival comes from the local population not tourists....what dies marketing "Junkanoo" mean? Why don't they send a Junkanoo group down to UWI in Jamaica and Barbados to perform as part of international students day? What exactly does "marketing" mean?

jamaicaproud 9 years, 11 months ago

I think Carnival outside of its original space Rio, Trinidad etc. Is a waste of time. Ina Jamaica the main defenders of this phenomenon are well traveled moneyed people who have "elevated themselves" above the local culture(s). Its is well attended it seems but does not attract tourists. For it to attract outsiders you guys would need a carnival that descends in risque behavior, and debauchery for freaky outsiders. You should petition against it.

duppyVAT 9 years, 11 months ago

Jamaica has 4 million people ..... DUHHHHH ......... We have a strong Junkanoo culture where the real Junkanoors will not buy into Carnival . regardless of what the Commission is saying

jamaicaproud 9 years, 11 months ago

Bruh I am agreeing with you but you are so antagonistic towards us you can't see.

worthlessbabydaddy 9 years, 11 months ago

@Thisisours I stand in total agreement with all that you've expressed. It would have been BEST to invest in a product indigenous to us, JUNKANOO. It's like we don't the faith in who we are and our culture to give rise to facilitating Carnival. I love music but I think we may have made a wrong decision by the introduction of this parade. With crime the way it is now...it has to be under control before tourists that plan on attending are not further and increasing victims to this negative socio-economic trend. I may be wrong but it is a waist!

asiseeit 9 years, 11 months ago

Most women I speak to say they do not go to Junkanoo because they do not want to get "felt up". I understand what they are saying as I have seen it with my own two eye's. Women are touched in ways that are not acceptable in any form or fashion. Good luck having any decent people attend this Carnival foolishness!

jackbnimble 9 years, 11 months ago

I say let's just boycott it to ensure that there is no repeat experience.

ThisIsOurs 9 years, 11 months ago

The carnival parties seem to be well attended, the open question is, how many of the young people attending at price of $20 are willing to pay between $400-$600 to participate in the street parade

duppyVAT 9 years, 11 months ago

Sooooooo, which Bahamian gonna pay $500 for a costume to parade????? Obie betta go find plenty bare-naked tourist revelers for that ....... Junkanoo has headpieces and costumes and Bahamians dance Junkanoo-style incognito for the most part .......... how many Bahamians will particpate in this vulgar public spectacle and PAY to do so???????????

ThisIsOurs 9 years, 11 months ago

that's a very good question

Sign in to comment