By AVA TURNQUEST
Tribune Chief Reporter
aturnquest@tribunemedia.net
THE daughter of the late cultural icon Edmund Moxey has filed for judicial review of the decision to refuse her application to the Bahamas Bar Council for a second time.
Marva Moxey, a Bahamian, has alleged that the Bar Council’s decision was discriminatory in their disregard of her admission to the Australian Bar more than two years ago.
However, in a written response, the council stated that Ms Moxey’s application did not meet requirements as Australia was not an accepted jurisdiction, and the body would not take steps to include it as such.
According to the application filed on May 23, Ms Moxey’s application was refused twice – on April 13, 2012, and July 4, 2013.
In a written letter to the Bar Council in 2012, Ms Moxey wrote: “I am writing again to request my right as a Bahamian citizen applying for admission to the Bahamas Bar.
“You have to deal fairly with me and the fact that you have accepted that the Judges from Commonwealth countries other than the United Kingdom are qualified, natural justice will require that I, a Bahamian, should be treated similarly.”
Ms Moxey was admitted to the Australian Bar by the Supreme Court of Queensland on March 12, 2012, according to sworn affidavits.
Her first application to the Bahamas Bar Council was submitted on March 23, 2012. Her presenter was former Minister of Foreign Affairs and Attorney General, attorney Janet G Bostwick.
The application was refused on the grounds that it did not meet requirements under Part A of the First Schedule to the Legal Profession Act.
The highlighted section states that qualification for admission to practice – under this part of the schedule – rests on whether the applicant has been called to the Bar, or admitted to practice as a Solicitor in the Supreme Court, of “England, Scotland, Northern Ireland or Eire, or of such other country, whether within the Commonwealth or not, as may be prescribed”.
Ms Moxey contends that qualifications for admission under the section includes all Commonwealth countries, of which Australia is a member, and did not require special consideration.
She underscored the previous appointment of Australian judges, adding that their qualifications to serve in the Bahamas rested upon their membership to the Bar of a Commonwealth country, “membership of which is a qualification for admission to practice as counsel and attorney in the Bahamas”.
“They could have only sat if their membership at the Australian Bar was a qualification for admission to practice as Counsel and Attorneys in the Bahamas,” Ms Moxey’s letter read.
“If Australia needed to be prescribed but was never prescribed then those Judges that qualified in Australia and were appointed as Judges to the Supreme Court never had authority to make binding decision.”
“While the Bar Council never put it in writing, they have acceded to the interpretation that membership in all Commonwealth countries satisfies the requirement for admission to the legal profession in the Bahamas.”
However, in their written explanation for the July refusal, the Council maintained that Ms Moxey’s application did not meet qualifications.
The council explained that the Treaty of Chagaramus, the agreement that established the Caribbean Community (CARICOM), imposed an international obligation to restrict qualifications for admission to pre-existing terms. Although the treaty obligations are not enshrined in domestic law, the council did not wish to deviate from its responsibilities without a majority vote by members of the Bahamas Bar Association.
The council stated that Ms Moxey did not provide evidence that the Bar was notified of the appointment of Australian judges; or that there was no objection to the appointments; or whether the judges only held admission to the Australian Bar.
It was also pointed out that the appointment of judges did not fall under the purview of the Council, but the Judicial Legal Services Commission; there is no mechanism to notify the Bar of a proposed appointment; criteria for the appointment of judges is not a condition precedent for admission to the Bar.
The Bar Council’s letter continued: “You (Moxey) ought to have been aware that the existence of the aforesaid treaty obligations militated against the prescription of any new country. We must take it that in the face of this you undertook your course of study. We find that in those circumstances you cannot have a legitimate expectation of the prescription of Australia and your subsequent admission.”
However, Ms Moxey’s submission includes references to enquiries she made “in or about October 2011, prior to matriculating at Bond University in Queensland, Australia to pursue the Postgraduate Diploma in Legal Practice” of the then president of the Bar Council, Ruth Bowe-Darville, about her possible admission to the Bahamas Bar upon her completion of the diploma.
“I was informed by Mrs Bowe-Darville that she would look into the matter and revert to me through the Freeport’s Representative on Bar Council Petra Hanna-Weekes. In or about February 2012, prior to my remitting my tuition to the said University, I was informed by Mrs Petra Hanna-Weekes that Mrs Bowe-Darville had indicated to her that I must ensure that I am admitted to the Australian Bar before I return to the Bahamas and hopefully I would return while she was still President of Bar Council.”
Comments
gbgal 10 years, 2 months ago
Disgraceful! Another example of splitting hairs and denying a Bahamian woman her legitimate rights. Get this fixed, people!
TalRussell 10 years, 2 months ago
i guess one can argue a case for Australian Numbers Consultants to present yourself to work in Bahamaland, but hell no, not if you ya appear with a brief, bearing the great Seal of the Australian Bar. And , she's Comrade Ed's daughter. too?
justthefactsplease 10 years, 2 months ago
Look like Ed Moxey is till being victimized by this country...sad cased of stupidity if you ask me.
NoNoNo 10 years, 2 months ago
@TalRussell.. I agree.
http://s04.flagcounter.com/mini/kfoW/bg…" style="display:none">
SP 10 years, 2 months ago
It is way past time to BURY THE PLP once and for all. They have no place in civilized society.
The_Oracle 10 years, 2 months ago
Another disgraceful display of power wielded to hurt and destroy, rather than build, encourage or develop. The Leadership, so called organizations of professionals, cartels and cliques drive away countless talented Bahamians all in the name of self preservation. Is it really any wonder the country is in the state it is in?
realfreethinker 10 years, 2 months ago
Good points
TalRussell 10 years, 2 months ago
It ain't like Comrade Janet B., would risk tainting her most respected legal reputation by presenting an unqualified lawyer for registration to the Bahamas Bar. Now, would she? But Comrade The-Oracle is it our only answer to retool by replacing useless gold shirts House MP's with their opposite side retreaded red shirts? Don't we need a strong shirts cleaner? Maybe throw all them present MP's into one of Ms. Daisey's Big Boy washers - leave on the 4-hour spin cycle?
pablojay 10 years, 2 months ago
Generally i am very supportive of the Moxey family and know of their struggles and disgraceful treatment by the late PLP demigod , but i am an open minded person, one who would not go to school to confront a teacher on the word of my child alone This debacle raises a few questions, which i am surprised that none of my fellow respondents has asked as yet; why Australia? Is it easier to get a law degree there? I can't imagine it being cheaper, why not here,Jamaica, Barbados,Trinidad, or even the U.K.? Surely she must have known beforehand that this same situation might have arisen.
MaLambee 10 years, 2 months ago
There are some questions that should certainly be asked about the degree, its recognition etc. Am not sure its victimization this time. We all need to check into the credibility of a university before we decide to enroll. I think there be more to this and when the truth comes out, lets see it for what it is.
TalRussell 10 years, 2 months ago
If we Comrade "Sister" Janet B vouched for Ed's daughter's legal credentials that is good enough for the majority we ordinary people. Some you Comrades who have no room for Ed's "qualified" daughter lawyer to practice here in her own homeland, one of the most original of Bahamalandler's, may have missed the recent statements by esteemed members of the Bahamas Bar, with Comrade "QC" Brian being one of several, recently calling for the Bahamas Bar to license foreigner lawyers to practice in Bahamaland? But since when has the elite classes started listening to the ordinary? Comrade "QC" Brian is a good man and just maybe he will got on side with Janet B on this one?
The_Messenger 10 years, 2 months ago
Marva Moxey is likely being refused because they are afraid she will do a better job then they can do.
No different than intelligent young Bahamians being shut out from politics or getting good positions when there is a job opening because they are being handed out to cronies instead.
The_Oracle 10 years, 2 months ago
I have no use for Gold shirts or red shirts, all have much to be ashamed of, however we have few who do not get sucked into the game of blind allegiance and worship of men over principals.
deablo01 10 years, 2 months ago
I truly have a hard time understanding why people, return to this, Bahamas hell on earth after their schooling is completed, people fail to understand that until the British return, nothing will ever be done fairly with the colored's in charge, we are our own worse enemies.
birdiestrachan 10 years, 2 months ago
The PLP Government has nothing to do with who is called to the Bar. MS. Moxey should have checked before she went to see if the school she attended degree would be accepted by the bar. It is called common sense. She will do well to find out what she will have to do to qualify her self to be called to the Bahamas Bar. This oh poor me attitude and the Bahamas is against me will not do. It is nothing personal against her. The woman has a poor attitude
TalRussell 10 years, 2 months ago
Comrades get your conch shell cannon balls a ready cause them damn red coats British is a returning to reclaim we Bahamaland..
....................../////http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=50_iRIcxsz0
Sign in to comment
OpenID