0

Does somebody have to die first?

The aftermath of the blaze in The Mud.

The aftermath of the blaze in The Mud.

By AVA TURNQUEST

Tribune Chief Reporter

aturnquest@tribunemedia.net

THE LINGERING stench of charred earth has intensified the anxiety of residents in the nation’s largest shanty town, The Mud, Abaco.

As families picked through the remains of their homes yesterday some thanked God that once again lives were spared in the blaze that tore through the area over the weekend.

Without the loss of life, though some asked whether officials were perhaps waiting for fatalities before they were forced to deal with The Mud and all its problems.

More than 30 homes were razed on Sunday in the second major blaze to rip through the settlement. Local officials and residents told The Tribune the community is under constant threat from fires and environmental hazards borne by the illegality of building practices.

“As a resident it makes me want to get out more,” said 37-year-old Bahamian carpenter Claude Daniel, who said he was not awarded citizenship until his early 30s despite having applied at 18.

“It just ain’t safe to be around no more,” he continued, “some people want to get out but people in their 30s and 40s still don’t have documents to go buy land. You can’t open a bank account, you can’t do nothing. It’s definitely a rock and a hard place, that’s what it is.”

“I’m gonna be all right but you have some young kids, they still out of school. I know young kids born in the country, seven or eight years old just walking around in the yard all day because they can’t go to school, but there’s laws. I’m not saying it’s right.

Mr Daniel added: “I’m saying God don’t sleep. They (Government) probably wait until they lose couple lives before they make any real change.”

With the devastation running parallel to the government’s renewed pledge to dismantle shanty towns across the country, speculation over possible linkages was rife among onlookers yesterday.

Of the residents canvassed, an overriding sentiment was the belief the characterization of the shanty town as a haven for illegal migrants has allowed successive governments to scapegoat their neglect of a community some residents claim is significantly occupied by Bahamians - whether naturalized or not.

“You can’t just bring a bulldozer and knock over everything, it would be a riot, but the last fire just happen two or three weeks ago,” said 27-year-old Bahamian Julia Forbes, who underscored the scarcity of affordable living accommodations on the island.

Ms Forbes, an expectant mother-of-five who travelled to the island for employment, told The Tribune she settled in the Mud after she was unable to afford available options which exceeded $2,000 per month. Her children live in Freeport with their father.

“I’m a Bahamian,” she continued, “I don’t have no Haitian descent. It was just no (affordable) apartments over here and I didn’t want to quit my job to move back to Nassau.

“I don’t know what I’m going to do,” said the young mother who is six months pregnant.

“At least I had my passport and my wallet but everything I owned was right in there because I was supposed to come right back.

“The rent was $200 a month, can’t beat that.”

The issue of electricity and its source in the Mud is unclear, with some residents claiming they get their power from the few electricity poles which border the many entrances to the settlement. The poles represent a long foregone era when the settlement enjoyed utilities like electricity and running water; the alleged disruption of those services in the early 90s was suggested to be politically motivated.

However, others underscored power is siphoned from a network of rented drop cords that run overhead and along the ground between generators.

Ms Forbes said there were different levels of residents, some of whom were living off-grid in complete disregard of laws, and others who subscribed to the comforts and norms of modern society.

Up to yesterday, the total number of residents displaced by the early morning blaze was 60 adults and 35 children. However, the official shelter designated by the government in partnership with the Red Cross was empty on Sunday night. Red Cross shelter manager Sarone Kennedy Sr said the total number of people registered was nine.

The Tribune was told displaced families were likely staying with relatives and friends, or at trusted churches, as they were especially vulnerable with all or most of their belongings, specifically their legal documents lost in the fire.

On Monday, DEHS Island Manager Kimberley Wells led a team of workers to survey the area and immediately treat any open bodies of standing water to prevent potential outbreaks and identify the removal of metals to prevent environmental contamination.

Ms Wells said: “The practices what goes on inside here it’s very disturbing because the septic system is not properly constructed and then you have the water. You could have any kind of outbreak at any time, it’s concerning. We come in here all the time we can’t just come in here when there’s fire.

“We can’t ignore what happens inside here that’s why my officers are always inside here treating and what not. They (residents) work with us, they sleep with some of us, so you have to be very concerned as to what’s going on around here. This is an accident waiting to happen, a deadly accident. Thank God no one lost their lives or anything like that but if you just look you still have all these houses connected basically to each other and it’s really concerning.”

In the January fire approximately 55 homes were destroyed, affecting 170 people. A 42-year-old man was subsequently arraigned in Abaco’s Magistrate’s Court on ten counts of arson.

Prime Minister Dr Hubert Minnis has since pledged that the area affected by the fire will be cordoned off and no structures allowed to be rebuilt there.

During his tour of the settlement following the January fire, Dr Minnis was embraced by an elderly permanent resident, 72-year-old Fillette François.

Yesterday, she told The Tribune she was still waiting on the assurances made during that visit. Her house was severely damaged by that fire and she now lives in a smaller structure on the compound she has lived on since 1992. She said she has put in an application for land papers but has not received a response in two years, and admitted she has no idea which agency to follow up with.

Ms François, who also cares for her 10-year-old grandson as his Bahamian father is incarcerated, said she will not leave her residence unless she is given some form of permanent accommodation.

“They don’t want me to stay there,” she said, “but if you don’t want me to stay there you have to give me somewhere to go. if you move out, you can’t get it, you don’t have no paper, that’s why I’m still here. If you want me to go you have to give me somewhere to go. People don’t know the law. I can’t live here (in rubble) but I been living here so long, I do my best to live by myself. I don’t like live for free, that’s why I apply for this property three years ago. I don’t like living free, I want the right things, that’s the Bahamas way, and they need the money, you can’t come in the Bahamas living free if you love this place.”

Ms François added: “I have permanent residency, so long I wait for that, but you know how your people go, sometimes they want give it to you, sometimes they don’t want to give it to you, sometimes they make you walk, walk, walk, but I wait, I know God is good.”

Yesterday, The Tribune witnessed Ministry of Works officials take measurements for the area and were told residents had been advised there would be no opportunity to rebuild regardless of adherence to regulations.

“I’m 33, squatters rights don’t apply for the Mud,” said Jackson Lamy, a naturalized Bahamian mechanic.

“Any place else, or for anyone else, but for Haitians or descendents of Haitians squatters rights don’t apply to you. When they say yuck out the book (passport), all of the books look the same. but it just don’t apply to us.”

Continued Mr Lamy: “Every time it burn, they tell you you can’t build, so what that telling you. They know that if it burn eventually all of us will go. But I don’t know where they want us to go.

“It wasn’t us, our parents came here and grow us up here, our mentality is here. (Parents) they ain’t teach us no other mentality all we know is here, you can’t blame us if all we know is this. If the government did want to help us they could have helped us from long time, they knew we were here, they ain help us. When we was growing up and others growing up behind us they ain’t helping them.”

Embittered by what he feels is the persistent injustice doled out to naturalized Bahamians of Haitian descent and their children, Mr Lamy yesterday suggested if the shanty town problem is not resolved the community will be filled with only Bahamian residents in less than 20 years.

He expressed disgust over what he felt was political exploitation of Bahamian voters in the Mud and Pigeon Peas, and subsequent neglect by successive administrations.

“We know what it is,” Mr Lamy continued, “but when it’s time for you to vote they know where to come. The road was so smooth and clean but everytime election come and go it’s hell with the road, hell with the Haitians until time to vote again. They don’t worry about us, no running water, no light, what you think they trying to tell us?

“It don’t make no sense (voting),” Mr Lamy said, “They tell you we gonna put running water and light right now, you see the FNM in power, where the light? Where the running water? But you hear they trying to evict us. (Dr Minnis) he didn’t tell us that, it was just everything gonna be straight, power get restored, water, good road.

“So now places burning, 100 persons going to look for apartment, another two weeks now another hundred, where we going to find it? Abaco ain’t that big, and they telling you don’t build, how you could tell me don’t build my mommy and aunty them out on the road? Where I gonna put them?”

Comments

Sickened 6 years, 8 months ago

I have nothing nice to say!

DonAnthony 6 years, 8 months ago

We have been plagued as country with a never ending succession of Gutless leaders, FNM and PLP alike. Perhaps nothing has held us back more in our development. Any person with common sense knows the solution to this vexing problem: regulaize in an expedited fashion those that qualify and deport the rest, with massive fines for any employers of illegal aliens. It is the common sense fair thing to do, no one should be in limbo all these years. Sadly I have an almost zero hope in it being done. It seems we can not address, much less solve any serious problem in this country.

DDK 6 years, 8 months ago

"We have been plagued as country with a never ending succession of Gutless leaders, FNM and PLP alike." TRUE AND SICKENING. I believe our current P.M. said, at the site of the last fire, that his would be the administration to sort out the growing shanty town mess. THE PEOPLE are still waiting. The Tribune's headline is a good one, but persons have died before in shanty town fires in Marsh Harbour. Perhaps they are waiting for mass casualties and the burning of the town.

Greentea 6 years, 8 months ago

Keep waiting. Minnis didnt have any guts or ideas before the election and he certainly doesn't have any now. I saw him on the campaign trail two elections ago, telling people what he was going to do. I will never forget it because the vendor he was speaking to indicated that he didn't need what Minnis offered because he already had it. He then asked Minnis what other ideas he had for him. Minnis had nothing. It was absolutely incredible to behold. HM was speechless, couldn't not prepare an immediate reply to a very sharp conch vendor and slithered away. I knew then as I do now, not to expect a dam thing but more of the same from a Minnis fronted government. The fella just don't have it. Mind you the PLP had to go - but it is clear to me that this government is just another twirl on the political merry-go-round.

joeblow 6 years, 8 months ago

We want to remind the PM that his Dec 31st deadline has long past. This is an excellent opportunity for the PM and Minister of Immigration to identify who is not here legally and process them to appear before the courts. Those without a constitutional right (ie a real Bahamian parent) can be housed at the detention center for repatriation. Its the humane and legal thing to do!

Greentea 6 years, 8 months ago

LOL! December 31st deadline? Did he tell you what year that December he was talking about was actually in? Certainly not 2017. Try the 31st of neverary.

TalRussell 6 years, 8 months ago

Ma Comrades, members Minnis's Imperial red cabinet's reactions to each and every Shantytown incident are no different than when Papa Hubert's red Imperials held reigns government... you does remember how he came by his handle - Papa?
Tis time for the formation of a strong-minded bo bullshi@ People's Libertarian Party

DDK 6 years, 8 months ago

Will you be the Leader, Comrade? Like the party name, just not the initials!

TalRussell 6 years, 8 months ago

My Comrade DDK, don't think some would looks too favourably towards my regular love Whisky and occasional home baked Brownies.

John 6 years, 8 months ago

Personally I think someone is trying to incite friction between Bahamians and Haitians with all these fires etc. And it has already been confirmed that not all people living in the shanty towns are Haitian and not all the Haitians in the shanty towns are illegal immigrants. And while we may not want the shantys in this country only a low life, sick minded criminal would set fire to the only belongings people have, without even the slightest consideration that lives may be lost, not excluding young children and infants even. Just hope that while the have you hating on the Haitians they are sneaking other nationalities in and giving them citizenship and the royal teatment

DDK 6 years, 8 months ago

There is so much Crown Land within walking distance of the town of Marsh Harbour, there is so much VAT money, so much customs duty money, so much numbers money (which should be national lottery money), why not get off derrieres and build low cost housing for those who qualify? I am SURE we MUST have honest, competent people in our Government who can organize such an undertaking. It is time the elected politicians and civil servants EARNED THEIR KEEP. Many of the people who have just lost everything do live in The Mud because they cannot afford high cost rentals and ARE legal Bahamians or on work permits. If building apartment units units or houses is too much of an undertaking, just provide low cost land with utilities in place. Obviously the men can build as many are employed in the construction trade.

Cas0072 6 years, 8 months ago

I hope you also consider the possibility that the sick minded individual could be one of those legalized or still illegal Haitians who want to get out and be relocated by the government. The article says it all. They want out, but don't want to face the true cost of living. While it is great that there were no injuries in either of these early morning fires, it is also enough to make one wonder.

Cas0072 6 years, 8 months ago

The sense of entitlement in this article reeks. The solution for Mr. Lamy, a naturalized Bahamian is very clear. He can struggle with market rent, utilities, etc. like all other Bahamians. Why can't he, his mother, and aunty put together to live in a safe environment with utilities in place? As for the carpenter, how about acknowledging and denouncing the the cluster you all create with the fraudulent documents and out of control birth rates? In the meantime, he too needs to deal with the high cost of living like everyone else. Ms. Francois, how about following up with the agency where you submitted the papers for the land? Just ridiculous.

Dawes 6 years, 8 months ago

Fully agree. As well as the lady with 5 kids already and another on the way. Why have so many if you are struggling to afford a place to live.

sealice 6 years, 8 months ago

alot of Bahamians feel the very same way as Mr. Lamy - what's the point of voting if you ain't a FNM or PLP peep you ain't getting schite once the elections over.... and that's not even mentioning race. . . .

birdiestrachan 6 years, 8 months ago

Excuses. excuses. It is every body fault but not those who built shanty Towns. Bahamians were never allowed to build shanty Towns. I am sorry they lost their homes. But where is their responsibility? Never mind what is said. they will build again very soon. No one has to set fires it may be drop cords.

alfalfa 6 years, 8 months ago

Tragic story. But time to face the facts. The Mudd is an illegal residential subdivision. Illegal BPL hookups; homes too close to each other; inadequate septic facilities; etc, etc,etc. Struggling working class Bahamians have to buy the land. Get plans drawn up. Fart around with the Ministry of Works, who seem to be lost in the wilderness; pay ridiculous fees to BPL for an electrical connection; then Water and Sewerage; then tip someone so that you can get a occupancy certificate; and on and on and on. This mess was allowed to develop when Edison Key brought in Haitians to work his farms and it has gotten out of hand because successive governments have done nothing to address this, and all of the other, shanty towns in the country. We have a vast majority FNM government who, unfortunately, are good at spinning yarns, but p-iss poor in taking action. So the Mudd and Pigeon Pea and all of the other shanty towns will continue to grow and continue to burn.

My2centz 6 years, 8 months ago

Smh at the perpetual victims. Why is the government being blamed for kids out of school when policy was rescinded months ago? Did Mr. Daniels submit all required documents when he applied at 18? I'd bet he didn't, and like many believe because his Haitian documents were difficult to obtain, it should be waived in the application process.

It seems Haitians are exempt from personal responsibility.

Ultimately living in a shanty town is a personal choice In the US illegals, and the working poor (no benefits), would live multiple families in a single family home to ensure running water, proper utilities and basic hygiene standards. In the Bahamas, multiple generations and extended families live together in similar cramped conditions. Even if the government provided low cost housing. I'd give it 5 years before it deteriorates to shanty town conditions with wooden structures intertwined with the concrete government ones, and is again overrun with illegals and illegality.

TheMadHatter 6 years, 8 months ago

"Ms Forbes, an expectant mother-of-five who travelled to..."

That's why Bahamians hate these bastards. How can you have nowhere to damn live with FIVE #%@£& kids and still get PREGNANT???? Or is she too stupid to know what causes pegnancy and the various forms of contraception available? Why do poor people like making more poor people? Is being poor that much fun?

I say to Hell with all of them. They have no respect and place no value on human life. To them babies are just something that "comes out" after sex...like snot comes out from the flu.

This woman is a careless and disgusting. Doesn't she care about the living conditions of her children? Does she plan on having a 7th?

joeblow 6 years, 8 months ago

You obviously don't know the high one gets from having dirty snotty nosed children running around that you can't afford to feed, clothe or love! That incredible feeling multiplies with each child.

There's nothing like it in all the world!

stillwaters 6 years, 8 months ago

“They don’t want me to stay there,” she said, “but if you don’t want me to stay there you have to give me somewhere to go'. The hell???????? So used to free stuff.............

TheMadHatter 6 years, 8 months ago

Actually, i think my comment was a bit harsh - even by my standards. I retract it, and apologize to any who were offended.

stillwaters 6 years, 8 months ago

I was definitely not offended........comment was how a lot of us feel about all these babies being born to these poor illegals.

One 6 years, 8 months ago

It is harsh; however uncontrolled and unregulated population growth is a global issue. Introducing another life into the world with no regard for your qualifications to raise a child is a tragic slippery slope.

bogart 6 years, 8 months ago

.......@Hatter.....you e xpress the frustrations of many....we are simply tired and vex at these challenges passed down fron adminto administration..everytime someone has a baby there are numerkous againcies govt officials involved fron the prenatial, doctors visits delivery, nib with their money per live birth...baby immunizations..perhaps social services....who could have advised her....govt even giv free condoms...

stillwaters 6 years, 8 months ago

To be fair..........we are placing blame on the Haitians having so many children, but Bahamian men are rutting about in this Haitian community, leaving babies behind too.

Sign in to comment