0

EDITORIAL: Was the DRA’s work worth the salary paid?

THE argument over the salary of the former managing director of the Disaster Reconstruction Authority (DRA), Katherine Forbes-Smith, is missing the point.

Whether Mrs Forbes-Smith should be paid the remainder of her salary will play out in the court. Ultimately, $110,000 a year for being in charge of the reconstruction of the hurricane-hit islands is not an outlandish sum. That’s a big responsibility, and should have a pay packet that is appropriate to the task.

The real question is whether or not the work she did matched up to the salary that she was given. In short, was she worth it?

Central and South Abaco MP John Pinder sums up the work of the DRA as “dismal, absolutely dismal”.

One of the stories that became a symbol of the lack of progress in recovering after Hurricane Dorian was the acquisition of domes to set up as temporary housing in Abaco – but more than a year after the storm, more than half of the domes still had to be set up. The people waiting on those domes had to find somewhere else in the meantime – so what was the point of the domes?

Mr Pinder had further criticism of the domes yesterday, saying: “They were never installed properly meaning the cesspit was never hooked up and needs to be regularly pumped out. These are the same areas that kids play around. Some of them don’t have electricity. Some of them are mould-infested, which is causing respiratory problems and on the whole, it was not only a bad decision, it was the wrong decision. It was something that is detrimental now to the health of Abaconians and the money we spent on that could have been utilised to put them in micro homes that would have been more suitable for a longer time frame.”

Time and again, The Tribune has heard stories of slow progress in the recovery after the storm, with a difficulty in securing supplies for repairs a recurring feature.

Mr Pinder also told of debris sites that were untended, and “many, many challenges” in Abaco.

So while the focus is on the details of Mrs Forbes-Smith’s contract, and whether it was a waste of money, there’s a far bigger question of whether money has been wisely spent in the work of the authority itself. Of course, we would hope there are lessons to be learned from the drafting of such contracts, including break clauses for targets not being met, but there’s a bigger issue here.

Some of these things – such as the domes – looked like a disaster in the making from the start, and pointed questions failed to bring satisfactory answers all through the process.

We would hope that the DRA will learn more than one lesson from all of this – about the contracts that are offered, but also about transparency and accountability. If some new scheme fails to deliver the way the domes project has done, we hope we hear the full story about it – not have to wait for another administration to come in to criticise it.

Most importantly, the people on the ground are still in need of help, and we ought to clear every obstacle out of the way in order to deliver it.

Hurricane Dorian was an event that shook the nation to its foundations, and recovering after that was always going to be a challenge. But this long after the event, we are still failing those who came through the storm. They need our support, and we need to deliver on our promise to be there to help.

Inflation

There is a lot of worry at present about the prospect of inflation bringing higher food costs for the coming year.

It shouldn’t be a new worry – The Tribune has been reporting on concerns raised by SuperValue’s Rupert Roberts for many months now. Mr Roberts has been vocal in warning his customers of the prospect of rising costs.

It’s also not an issue only affecting us. You only need to look at warnings across the water in the US about rising prices, and inflation in the UK has hit a 30-year high this year, with residents warned they could face a rise of about $2,700 equivalent in the cost of living this year.

Some of this is down to increased fuel costs, some of it is down to supply chain problems, but one thing is for certain – we can’t avoid the increased cost so we’d best get used to it. If we want to ship food into the country, we have to pay what it costs for the container and the fuel to ship it.

So rather than stick our heads in the sand and try to ignore the problem, there is something we can do about it.

Early in the COVID-19 pandemic, a number of residents started their own gardens, growing food for their homes. Why not take the initiative now and follow in their footsteps? Our gardening columnist, Adam Boorman, in the Weekend section is always worth a read for good advice as you go. And perhaps there might be a satisfaction to look forward to on the day you serve your family a meal grown in your own garden. It might not save a lot, but every little helps.

Comments

birdiestrachan 2 years, 9 months ago

No way MS Smith should have been paid such a high salary. They keep the bodies of those who had died in trailers for such a long time then had a big fanfare.

The former PM created this agency when there were already agencies in place just so he could give her this huge salary while there was no bed in the hospital for poor sick people.

If the PLP had done this there would be an outcry from the Editorial page. but the FNM did it so it is all right

She was also a consultant for a cruise port. It was the peoples time all right her and the doc time..

ThisIsOurs 2 years, 9 months ago

I agree with you on the personal assessment of the motivations. It appeared to me like a grab for the billions in donor funds coming into the country. The ministry otherwise made no sense. I notice the PLP hasnt disbanded it either

ThisIsOurs 2 years, 9 months ago

"One of the stories that became a symbol of the lack of progress in recovering after Hurricane Dorian was the acquisition of domes to set up as temporary housing in Abaco – but more than a year after the storm, more than half of the domes still had to be set up. The people waiting on those domes had to find somewhere else in the meantime – so what was the point of the domes?"

You forget the most egregious part about the SIX MILLION DOLLAR domes. The reason given by Mrs Smith for them not being set up. "Installation is very expensive" I believe she quoted a cost of a few thousand dollars*

She should have been fired for incompetence "in that role" the next day. Which manager completes a procurement exercise then tells their boss, well we cant use the equipmemt because it costs too much to set it up. Its such a visionless posture. When you procure goods its ALWAYS a part of a plan. And that plan includes how youre going to get the equipment from the accounting department straight up to use by the customer. The fact that she didnt do that says she was unqualified for the role of a disaster manager. Because that one thing is all (well a giant chunk of what) disaster managers do, "logistics".

birdiestrachan 2 years, 9 months ago

66 thousand gratuities if that is not an outlandish sum What is?

The Abaco people are also stuck with domes just more rubbish How will they be disposed of?

ThisIsOurs 2 years, 9 months ago

We should find out how much they pay in the north pole for an igloo

sheeprunner12 2 years, 9 months ago

I do agree that it doesn't look right for these political cronies to get fat off other people's pain and donations, but the PLP will do it too .......... NEMA, DRA and all of the other agencies will not be disbanded by the PLP .......... That is why we must say hats off to Red Cross & BASRA (true volunteers)

Sign in to comment