The National Insurance Board (NIB) is the government agency responsible for managing the country’s social security system. The NIB provides various social security benefits, including pensions, disability benefits, maternity benefits, funeral benefits and unemployment benefits. NIB was established on October 7, 1974, by the National Insurance Act, which was passed by the Government in 1972. NIB is funded through contributions from both employees and employers, and the programme is managed by a Board of Directors appointed by the minister responsible for NIB. Over the years, NIB has undergone several changes and expansions, including the establishment of a medical benefits scheme and the introduction of electronic services to enhance its operations and improve its service delivery.
Since the establishment of the Fund, concerns have been raised about sustainability and proper management of monies. Many experts, including actuarial scientists, have suggested incremental increases in contribution rates to ensure the $1.5bn reserve fund’s longevity. Events such as COVID-19 have only increased the urgency for significant increases in contribution rates from Bahamians. In this segment, we will discuss the need for reform, the state of NIB and what are the next best steps.
The need for reform
There have been calls for reforms at NIB in recent years primarily due to concerns about the programme’s long-term financial sustainability. In common with many social security initiatives, NIB relies on contributions from both employees and employers to fund its operations and pay benefits to participants. However, there have been concerns about the adequacy of NIB’s funding and the programme’s ability to meet its financial obligations in the future. Some analysts have suggested NIB may need to consider adjustments to its benefit structure, eligibility criteria and/or contribution rates to ensure long-term viability. Other issues that have been raised in relation to NIB include concerns about the programme’s efficiency, transparency and accountability.
The Government has recently suggested a contribution rate hike is essential to sustain NIB, especially given the excessive depletion of funds during the COVID-19 pandemic. However, prior to COVID, concerns have always been raised about the fund’s financial health. NIB has commissioned several actuarial reports over the years, and these reports have made various recommendations to improve its financial viability. It was revealed in the 11th actuarial review that NIB’s reserve fund could be depleted by 2028. That report reduced the fund’s potential depletion timeline by one year, as the 10th review had made a prediction of 2029. This signals that, despite unforeseen events such as the COVID pandemic, NIB was always in a vulnerable position. Over the years, these reports have acted as warning signals on the need for reforms to ensure NIB is financially secure. It was only in a time of crisis that we saw the value of NIB and used it to temporarily bail us out. Now, the fund is in a worse position than it was before the pandemic. It would simply be unfair to adjust rates because of poor planning when there was always an opportunity to have incremental increases in a phased manner. With no indication of full economic recovery or growth, further taxing Bahamians is an unrealistic approach to a solution.
Some of the recommendations made by these reports over the years include:
Adjusting contribution rates: Actuarial reports have recommended that NIB adjust its contribution rates to ensure it is collecting sufficient revenue to fund its operations and pay benefits to programme participants. The reports have suggested that NIB may need to increase contribution rates to address funding gaps or to ensure that the programme remains financially sustainable over the long-term.
Reforming benefit structures: Actuarial reports have also recommended that NIB consider reforming its benefit structures to ensure they are aligned with the programme’s financial resources. This could involve adjusting eligibility criteria, reducing benefit levels or increasing the retirement age to ensure the programme remains sustainable over the long-term.
Improving investment strategies: Actuarial reports recommended that NIB improve its investment strategies to generate higher returns on its investments. This could involve diversifying the programme’s investment portfolio, investing in higher-yielding assets or engaging in other strategies to improve investment returns.
The impact of COVID-19
The COVID-19 pandemic had a significant impact on NIB, leading to an estimated 11 percent decline ($189m) in its reserve funds during 2020. In addition to benefit payouts, NIB also introduced special assistance programmes such as the Unemployment Benefit Extension programme and the COVID-19 assistance programme to provide financial support to eligible workers affected by the pandemic.
It was reported that unemployment and short-term benefits tripled because of the pandemic due to the increased demand for some of the benefits offered by NIB. At the end of December 2020, benefits paid were over $405m, representing a 30.2 percent year-over-year increase. Shortly after these numbers were revealed, there were calls for a rate hike to help sustain the fund at the risk of many Bahamian families not being able to receive pensions or benefits. It appears that before committing funds from NIB to assist Bahamians, not all factors were considered. For instance, the specific amount of money taken from NIB during the pandemic depended on the number of people receiving benefits, the duration of their benefits, and the overall economic impact of the pandemic. These factors should be quantified, but no data was provided to the public on the impact of this decision. Therefore, we are now once again left to pick up the pieces of poor planning.
The National Development Plan
The National Development Plan (NDP) can indirectly help sustain and grow NIB by creating a favourable environment for economic growth and development in the country. Economic growth can help to create new jobs and income opportunities, which also increases the number of contributors to NIB and reduces the demand for certain payments such as unemployment benefits. Additionally, economic growth can increase the programme’s revenue by increasing the total wages and salaries earned by workers in the country that are subject to NIB contributions. The NDP can also help NIB by addressing some of the social and economic challenges faced by The Bahamas. For example, the NDP includes measures to address poverty, inequality and access to healthcare, which can help to reduce the demand for certain NIB benefits such as social assistance and healthcare benefits. Furthermore, the NDP can provide a framework for collaboration and co-operation between the NIB and other government agencies, private sector organisations and civil society groups. This can help to improve the co-ordination of social and economic policies, which can help to create a more favourable environment for NIB and other social security programmes to operate.
Conclusion
Reforming NIB is crucial to ensure that The Bahamas’ social security system remains financially sustainable and provides adequate support to its beneficiaries. The COVID-19 pandemic has highlighted the importance of social security programmes such as NIB in providing a safety net for vulnerable individuals and families in times of crisis.
Reforms to NIB could involve a range of measures, including adjusting contribution rates in a phased manner, reforming benefit structures, improving investment strategies, and strengthening governance and management practices. It is important that any reforms are designed to ensure NIB remains financially sustainable over the long-term, while also providing adequate support to programme beneficiaries. To achieve this, it is important to engage in open and transparent consultations with stakeholders, including government officials, NIB management and staff, employers, workers and civil society groups. Collaboration and co-operation among stakeholders is crucial to ensure that NIB remains responsive to the changing social and economic conditions in The Bahamas, and that it continues to meet the evolving needs of its beneficiaries.
Reforming NIB is an important step towards building a more inclusive and sustainable social security system in The Bahamas. With careful planning and effective implementation, reforms to NIB can help ensure the programme remains financially sustainable and provides adequate support to its beneficiaries for years to come.
Commenting has been disabled for this item.