Ethical cultures can deteriorate through a series of seemingly minor decisions. A questionable transaction goes unchallenged because an executive approved it. An audit finding is softened to preserve a sensitive relationship. A director withholds an objection because the decision appears settled. Individually, these moments seem manageable. Collectively, they shape what employees are prepared to question and what leaders become accustomed to accepting. Over time, silence becomes an established corporate behaviour. I explored this ethical dilemma during the Bahamas Institute of Chartered Accountants (BICA) accountants' week 2026, examining how leadership influences ethical behaviour and accountability.
This article examines how leadership behaviour influences ethical silence, why professional relationships can complicate accountability, and how companies can distinguish genuine agreement from the absence of challenge.
Silence develops through experience
Employees learn what is acceptable by observing leadership. A manager who invites questions during training, but dismisses them during meetings, sends conflicting messages. An executive who praises transparency but sidelines an employee after an uncomfortable disclosure creates an expectation that speaking up carries consequences.
Consider a financial controller questioning revenue recognised ahead of a refinancing deadline. The chief executive argues that changing the figures could endanger financing and employment. The controller understands the professional obligation but also recognises the influence of the executive who supported their career. The accounting requirement remains unchanged. The perceived cost of challenging the decision does not.
The Association of Chartered Certified Accountants (ACCA) 2026 Navigating Ethics for Trust report found that 53 percent of surveyed finance and accountancy professionals had witnessed unethical behaviour during the preceding three years, while 22 percent reported pressure to act unethically. Although these findings are international, they illustrate the pressures that can test professional judgement.
Relationships complicate accountability
In a relatively small business community such as The Bahamas, professional and commercial relationships frequently intersect. A supplier may also be a long-standing client, while directors and executives may maintain relationships across several companies. These connections can strengthen trust and co-operation. However, they can also create circumstances where familiarity, loyalty or perceived obligations influence how individuals approach difficult decisions and professional challenges.
The danger develops when personal confidence replaces independent judgement. Over time, exceptions can become expectations, and governance processes lose their ability to challenge decisions effectively.
Leadership determines the response
Boards frequently assess ethical culture through training completion, whistleblowing statistics and policy reviews. These indicators provide useful information, but they cannot establish how employees experience leadership.
Zero complaints may indicate limited misconduct. It may also reflect limited confidence in reporting arrangements. Leaders should examine the independence of investigations, how concerns reach the Board and what happens to employees after raising difficult issues.
Effective governance requires leaders to accept challenge without treating disagreement as disloyalty. It also requires the discipline to investigate concerns fairly, including those that ultimately prove unfounded.
In short, ethical silence develops through behaviours leaders repeatedly tolerate. Companies that value accountability must examine the messages their decisions send. The next time a meeting ends without objection, leadership should ask whether agreement was earned or silence was learned.
• NB: About Derek Smith Jr
Derek Smith Jr has been a governance, risk and compliance professional for more than 20 years with a leadership, innovation and mentorship record. He is the author of ‘The Compliance Blueprint’. Mr Smith is a certified anti-money laundering specialist (CAMS) and holds multiple governance credentials. He can be contacted at hello@pineapplebusinessconsultancy.com



Comments
Use the comment form below to begin a discussion about this content.
Sign in to comment
OpenID