PICTURES of a Blue Marlin posted to the Walker’s Cay Facebook page.
Reader poll
Do you agree that sport fishing for blue marlin should be stopped?
- Yes
- No
160 total votes.
By EARYEL BOWLEG
Tribune Staff Reporter
ebowleg@tribunemedia.net
AN environmental activist has slammed the landing of blue marlins in a recent three-day Walker’s Cay Invitational deep sea fishing contest.
Sam Duncombe, reEarth’s president, called it “absolutely ludicrous” that the capture of the country’s national fish is allowed in such events, adding these “bloody tournaments” need to stop.
The invitational took place between May 26-29 at Walker’s Cay. According to the property’s website, the cay is 53 miles to the northeast of West End, Grand Bahama and its “rebirth is underway” thanks to entrepreneur and “marlin fishing enthusiast” Carl Allen.
The website noted that to participate in the tournament, all teams were required to possess a Bahamas fishing permit. The tournament rules also stated that blue marlin were eligible for catch and release or eligible for weigh-in “with a minimum 101” LJFL (lower jaw to fork length) measurement requirement, however only one per boat may be killed per fishing day.”
Gregory Bethel, acting director of the Department of Marine Resources, confirmed it was a permitted activity. Mr Bethel noted the Fisheries Resources (Jurisdiction and Conservation) Regulations states any billfish, such as marlins or swordfish, caught shall be returned to the sea unharmed except where landed under the terms of an approved sword fishing event or tournament.
The cay’s official Facebook page posted pictures and videos of the teams catching the country’s national fish and the size of the fish they reeled in. One team was pictured posing and smiling next to a blue marlin hanging upside down.
“Team Wave Paver, 77’ Baylis, brought in the first blue marlin to the gantry! Congratulations guys, 508 lbs!” the caption read.
In the comments, the page wrote: “Tournament update! We have released 17 blue marlins, two have been brought to the scales and all of the catch has been donated to our friends at Grand Cay! Teams are battling it out to the finish line for top overall team and largest blue marlin.”
But in the mix of congratulatory messages were angry individuals upset that anyone is still able to land blue marlin.
However, Mr Bethel explained to The Tribune: “Normally 99.9 percent of the time you would find that with respect to billfish, they normally practice catch and release, but in the case of where you would land a blue marlin similar to the one in Walker’s Cay where the minimum length is 96 inches, what we consider a prize or trophy fish, they’re allowed to land because the length 96 inches is equivalent to just around 500 pounds… that means it’s a huge fish.”
When contacted for a reaction, Ms Duncombe criticised the sport as she highlighted how the fish’s life could be at risk due to sharks possibly catching them when they are released.
“This is a barbaric, sadistic sport and the fact that in 2021 we’re still allowing the capture of the lions and tigers of our ocean is absolutely ludicrous,” she said. “I mean at one point and time, do we evolve to the point where we understand the impact that we’re having on those individual animals?
“Can you imagine being dragged in the sea half drowned by the time they release you, if they’ve released you, all that thrashing that’s going on is attracting sharks and essentially those animals can be caught by sharks after their ordeal. I mean I don’t know what kind of sadistic psychopathic person would consider that a sport for fun. It is absolutely ludicrous that we are allowing the capture of our national fish. You think the Americans are catching the bald eagle?
“I don’t care who it is with our national fish — it needs to stop. We need to stop having these bloody tournaments. I mean what is the difference between killing a blue marlin and going into Africa and shooting a lion? There’s no difference. Those are the top predators of the ocean and the top predators on land.”
The IUCN Red List of Threatened Species has listed the blue marlin as being “vulnerable,” meaning the fish is “at high risk of extinction in the wild”. With blue marlins being threatened, the activist argued for no more fishing of the animal.
She added: “The whole sidebar of ‘oh, but we share it with everybody on the island’ that’s the exact same thing that the people who killed the lions and tigers would say about that. With an animal that is threatened you know you err on the side of conservation. That has been our problem that we never err on the side of conservation.”
Comments
tribanon 2 years, 11 months ago
Sam Duncombe should better spend her time fighting true environmental causes, like the cruise ship industry.
C2B 2 years, 11 months ago
Can do both. Not mutually exclusive.
Proguing 2 years, 11 months ago
Looks like plunder to me....
TalRussell 2 years, 11 months ago
Why having Thee Comrade Mr. Minnis as Chief Advocacy Officer for Saving Androsian Crabs is turning into such an unexpected godsent of a blessin' thing. Amen, yes?
C2B 2 years, 11 months ago
This is not a Sport but a pastime. Sports are defined by their domination by Athletes; people who are in the top physical condition. Fat old white guys and their entourages just don't meet that criteria.
stislez 2 years, 11 months ago
Perfect example of how our people are treated. Thats our national fish and they allowing non nationals to catch it, the same way this our land and they allow the foriegners to buy it out from under us. Only could be 3rd world intelligence. I mean what do you expect when our government practically does beg dese white men for their money. We is a beggin culture, dont know how to handle our own then want go beg for more. I wish the pirates was still around to go out der an sink all dem sport fishers boats an take dey booty. Dese man dem.have cays to deysef, only jah kno wa dey out there doing een like they being watched. Just how disney dem was destroying the coral reefs and releasing waste in our water lonnnnnnnngggggggggggg before anyone find out is the same way these white people out there doing what they want. The level of trust our government does put in these white people believeing they ga do whats right without supervision is just crazy to me! You know we is say give dem a inch dey ga take a yard..................our government does GIVE dem a yard to take off the bat!
TalRussell 2 years, 11 months ago
Regardless of reEarths Comrade Sister Sam Duncombe's best monthly urge be at slaughtering we most-cherished eatin' thing, Conch is still we realm's National Dish. Okay, got it?
It is absolutely ludicrous that for Comrade Sister Sam, she is not sufficiently to content herself with the Blue Marlin, already sharing our $100 Bank Note** with the portrait mug we beloved Queen Liz, yes?
tribanon 2 years, 11 months ago
What these sport fishermen take from our waters pales in comparison to the huge daily hauls of the Dominican and Cuban commercial fishing vessels.
jus2cents 2 years, 11 months ago
FACT: There is ZERO SPORT involved in this kind of Deep Sea, 'sport fishing' (Not fishing for personal use / food)
I have seen them getting on their professional fishing boats, they have so much fishing tackle its obvious they are over fishing our seas for Commercial Profits, and Not fishing for personal use / food. ALL of these 'Sports Fishing Boats' take more than their quota, and some taking as much as poachers from Haiti or Dominica. They get onboard with cases and cases of Ziplock bags, stacks of industrial size coolers, men hired to JUST clean the fish caught. Some of the mega yachts fly in professional crews from South America on private jets, all with brand new fishing equipment, wearing the boat logo on shirts and uniforms. It is slaughter on a massive scale, and a lot of garbage and hooks are left floating in the sea.
One day not so far away in the future, we will look back at this time and see these cowardly sport/hunters for what they are, they will be regarded in the same way as people hunting giraffes, elephants and loins are now.
Its just Plain Wrong. And anyone trying to justifying it is kidding themselves.
Please Wake UP, before its all gone and too late to fix!
tribanon 2 years, 11 months ago
Are you really expecting Minnis to do anything meaningful about the ever diminishing marine life in our territorial waters? He doesn't even care about the pollution of our waters (and air) by the cruise ship industry.
Sign in to comment
Or login with:
OpenID