BY ANNELIA NIXON
TRIBUNE Business Reporter
anixon@tribunemedia.net
WATER taxi fares between Eleuthera and Harbour Island are set to increase from December 14, with one Briland hotelier warning that the cumulative impact from such increases could deter the upper middle class travellers who sustain much of the island’s tourism economy.
According to a November 13 public notice, Briland Water Taxi Owners & Operators fares between government docks will increase to $7 per person, while trips from private docks will rise to $13. The discounted rate for workers will remain at $5, while children under 12 will now be charged $3.
Henry Rolle, managing partner of The Rock House, said the increases come as Harbour Island businesses are already adjusting to higher operating costs and passing some of those expenses on to customers.
“The workers are still the same at $5, so that hasn't really been raised.,” he said. “They're charging for children now, $3. The extra $13 for a private dock, that's new as well. At least the workers aren't getting hit as hard as everyone else.”
However, he warned that the additional transportation costs could further undermine the affordability of visiting Harbour Island, particularly for middle and upper middle income travellers who represent a significant portion of the island's tourism market.
“You have the ridiculously wealthy that own homes on the island, and then they have their friends come and visit and associates,” Mr Rolle said. “But the majority of revenue is generated by the upper middle class. So that's the market that we kind of focus on.
“Right now, the 1 per cent that definitely has homes here and their friends, they'll be fine. They won't mind paying it. It's going to be more of a deterrent for the upper middle class because you have the airport fees, plus the increases in water taxis, the land taxis, plus increases in the hotels and restaurants. This is compounding. So this is going to be a very interesting season.”
Mr Rolle disclosed that The Rock House has increased its hotel rates by a combined 30 per cent over the past 12 months, while restaurant prices have risen by 20 per cent over the same period.
“Depending on how much of the 1 per cent visits Harbour Island, how much they spend, we may have to increase again,” he said. “So this doesn't make me relaxed. Let me put it that way.”
Mr Rolle said he expects less travel and reduced visitor spending, adding that some of those changes are already becoming apparent among guests. He pointed to some visitors who are now being more selective with their spending, including splitting meals, ordering cheaper menu items and eating at local establishments.
“The reality of the situation is we definitely will have less travel,” he said. “We will have less people spending, and we've noticed already because we can tell the people that have saved year-round to visit Harbour Island in the last, let's say, week-and-a-half, two weeks, they're the ones that are spending a lot less.”
While acknowledging the need for businesses and operators to adjust their prices to reflect rising costs, Mr Rolle said the broader economic circumstances are creating an increasingly difficult environment for the tourism industry.
“We're creating an unfortunate situation for ourselves,” he said. “That's all. I mean, look, prices have to go up. People have to make money. I wish it wasn't the case, but again, people have to look at this realistically.”
Mr Rolle added that he had developed four possible scenarios for the industry, saying the current situation had reached his third scenario and was moving towards what he described as a critical-case scenario.
Meanwhile, Leatendore Percentie, who commutes between mainland Eleuthera and Harbour Island almost daily, said he was frustrated by the fare announcement, particularly given what he described as long-standing operational and customer service problems among water taxi operators.
Mr Percentie, who said he travels by ferry every day for work, argued that higher fares should be accompanied by improvements in service standards, accountability and passenger safety.
“Yes, one can argue that because the price of gas is going up, they do deserve consideration there,” he said. “I cannot argue with that. But then again, we cannot close our eyes to many of the other issues. Some people feel that the water taxis are the weakest link in our tourism industry because of what goes on with water taxis.”
Mr Percentie argued that the absence of established departure schedules and an organised system for assigning boats also disproportionately affects workers who rely on the service to get to and from their jobs.
According to Mr Percentie, commuters can be left waiting for extended periods while operators prioritise tourists or private charters, sometimes leaving passengers who have already been waiting at the dock behind.
On another occasion, he said, a journey from Three Island Dock to Harbour Island's government dock, which ordinarily takes about five minutes, took one hour and five minutes because of waiting time and stops at private docks to accommodate tourists.
“So we are really being treated as second-class citizens by the ferry boat drivers,” Mr Percentie said. He added that a formal roster and consistent departure arrangements would help address some of the problems, particularly for commuters who need to arrive at work on time.
“The only thing that I can say, I don't mind them raising the fee to accommodate the gas, but it has to be a two-way street,” he said. “They have to listen to their passengers, and there has to be some adjustment in their behaviour,” he said.
Mr Percentie estimated that between 1,200 and 1,500 workers travel between mainland Eleuthera and Harbour Island on any given day, making the service particularly important to the island's workforce even during the slower tourism months of September and October.
Beriska Moss, marina manager at Ramora Bay Resort and Marina, said she had heard about the planned increases several months ago but had not seen the circulated public notice. She said regular visitors may have concerns about the adjustments, although she acknowledged that rising costs are affecting businesses and consumers worldwide.
“The first time persons, this will be their first time experiencing that,” she said. “Now, the persons that come here on a regular basis, they may have some dispute about it. But everything's going up in the world, so there's nothing much we can do about it,” Ms Moss said.



Comments
Use the comment form below to begin a discussion about this content.
Sign in to comment
OpenID