Govt ‘cannot continue to dodge’ liveable wage

Obie Ferguson, president of the Trade Union Congress. Photo: Dante Carrer/Tribune Staff

Obie Ferguson, president of the Trade Union Congress. Photo: Dante Carrer/Tribune Staff

By NEIL HARTNELL

TRIBUNE Business Editor

nhartnell@tribunemedia.net

THE BAHAMAS “cannot continue to dodge” the imposition of a livable wage, a trade union leader is asserting, arguing that its introduction must go hand in hand with the drive for greater economic productivity.

Obie Ferguson KC, the Trades Union Congress (TUC) president, told Tribune Business that the push for increased output by Bahamian workers must be directly tied to the labour movement’s long called-for shift from a minimum to a livable wage to ease ever-escalating cost pressures on local families.

While backing improved productivity as “critical” and “absolutely essential” for the Bahamian economy’s sustainability and long-term competitiveness, he argued that this can only be achieved by employers, workers and the Government collaborating together rather than continuing to operate “single-handedly” as often occurs.

Mr Ferguson spoke out after the National Productivity Task Force’s report to the Government, released last week, asserted that reforms which increase worker output and lower unit production costs can drive “the creation of 10,000 new jobs” across key Bahamian industries over the next five years through to 2031.

The study, which set the target of growing worker output by 24 percent over that same period, added that “sustained political will” and “buy-in” from all relevant stakeholders - the Government, businesses, unions and workers and wider civil society - are key to enabling the creation of the proposed National Productivity Innovation and Competitiveness Council and ensuring the reforms achieve their underlying productivity improvement objectives.

“The main challenge is gaining stakeholder buy-in from government levels, civil society and private/public sectors,” the National Productivity Task Force report warned. “Resistance arises from fear of change, distrust and concerns over control. To combat this, communication strategies, workshops and seminars are planned to encourage full participation and support…”

Pia Glover-Rolle, minister of labour, the public service and National Insurance, in a voice note responding to Tribune Business inquiries, said she was unable to say when the proposed Council will be formed or start its work. Legislation to give the Council’s work legal authority and underpinning must first be passed by Parliament.

The minister, to whom the Task Force’s report was sent, added that the Government is examining how the Council would interact with the National Development Plan (NDP) and the latter’s secretariat. The NDP is also awaiting passage of legislation that would place The Bahamas’ first-ever Planning Institute on a legal footing.

Explaining that she was in Geneva, Switzerland, on government business, Mrs Glover-Rolle said: “The Productivity Task Force has completed their work. I cannot say when the Council is going to begin its work. We are looking at how it interfaces with the National Development Plan and National Development Plan secretariat.”

Don Williams, the Bahamas Chamber of Commerce and Employers’ Confederation’s (BCCEC) chairman and chief executive, told this newspaper yesterday that the private sector advocacy group views the Council’s creation, and implementing the “road map” set out in the Task Force report, as being of “high importance”.

He added that the Chamber and business community are even prepared to step in and “push as far as possible”, given the importance of greater productivity to The Bahamas’ economic future, if the Government does “not take it as far as we’d like”.

However, Mr Williams rejected Mr Ferguson’s goal for an immediate move towards a livable wage, pointing out that the minimum wage was raised by $50 to $260 per week some three-and-a-half years ago, and that businesses are in no position to absorb a further hike in labour costs given the ever-increasing operating expenses they are already grappling with.

The TUC president, though, confirmed to this newspaper his and the wider union community’s desire for any productivity reforms and improvements to be tied directly to the imposition of a so-called livable wage.

“We’re not opposed to productivity,” Mr Ferguson told Tribune Business. “That is critical and is absolutely essential. What we also want is the equivalent of the livable wage. We don’t have a problem. We believe that productivity is essential for any commercial business but, equally important, we maintain that the standard of living has to be increased because $260 per week is not adequate.

“We cannot continue to dodge that. The Bahamas needs to have a livable wage.” When asked whether he was directly tying productivity reforms and improvements to the implementation of a livable wage, Mr Ferguson replied: “That’s correct. That’s essentially what we are suggesting.”

A University of The Bahamas study, dated September 30, 2020, and authored by Lesvie Archer, Olivia Saunders, Bridget Hogg, Vijaya Permual and Brittney Johnson, concluded that a living wage in New Providence and Grand Bahama is $2,625 and $3,550 per month respectively.

“Our gross living wage estimate for New Providence is 26 percent lower than the Grand Bahama living wage estimate, nearly 200 percent higher than the national minimum wage, 127 percent higher than 2013 poverty line and nearly 75 percent higher than the minimum wage hike proposed by a local union,” they wrote.

“Our living wage estimate for Grand Bahama is 200 percent higher than the 2013 poverty line and 140 percent higher than the minimum wage hike proposed by a local union.” Both the New Providence and Grand Bahama livable wage figures are more than double, and triple, respectively, than the present monthly minimum wage of $1,040 (based on 28 days) or $1,170 (based on 31 days).

The University of The Bahamas (UoB) findings met with instant push back from the private sector given that implementing them would cause their most expensive line item - labour costs - to explode and likely put many companies out of business. The definition of what exactly is a ‘livable wage’, and working out an actual figure, will likely prove extremely problematic.

And improved productivity, which increases economic output and lowers per worker costs, should ultimately be felt by both business profits and staff in the form of higher wages. Mr Ferguson conceded that higher Bahamian productivity is “very, very, very, very important” for the country’s economic future and sustainability.

“It has far-reaching effects on working people,” he told Tribune Business. “We have over 230,000-plus Bahamian workers. Do you realise the impact that would have on those workers of productivity is taken to another level? That will have a serious and positive impact on our economy.

“If we work together we won’t have a problem. The TUC is willing to meet and discuss how we can make this country a better country, and how we can survive, ultimately, in difficult times. When we want to operate single-handedly, that’s when we have a problem. That’s what’s happening in The Bahamas today. No business can operate successfully like that. No country can operate successfully like that.

“You have the businessman, the trade unions, the workers and the Government. If we sit down as mature people with a love for our country we can find ways to work together and improve this country. We are not where we ought to be, and it’s simply because we have people who believe they can do it all by themselves. That cannot work, and won’t work. If the country’s doing well, not only for businessmen but the workers, the workers must be part of the process.”

Mr Williams, at the Chamber, said of the private sector’s perspective on the productivity reform proposals: “We do consider it of high importance. Obviously, efficiency is not just about digitisation but it spans, in terms of people… We want to ensure we keep ourselves educated and keep up with the highest standards so that we’re not only productive in the workforce by productive in society as well.”

Agreeing that it falls to the Government to take the lead by passing the enabling legislation to create the Council, Mr Williams added: “From a private sector standpoint, our goal is to take the comments, questions, concerns and advice from all sectors, and if the Government does not take it as far as we’d like it to go, it will be pushed as far as possible from the private sector end.

“We ask schools to ensure the workforce is prepared, but we are now to the point where we need to be more integrated and intentional to ensure we in the private sector provide everything and facilitate that opportunity to ensure we have a productive workforce as well.”

The Chamber chair, explaining the private sector’s concerns over a shift to a ‘livable wage’, or even increasing the minimum wage, said: “Right now, there are heavy cost pressures. The minimum wage was increased just recently. We know the unions are pushing for it to increase again, but before it is increased again we need to see a level of productivity, we need to see boots on the ground. A business owner has to be able to feel that.

“Businesses need to experience a certain level of economies of scale before we take on additional labour costs…. There are a lot of factors affecting businesses and, right now, we feel an increase in labour costs will be an additional burden at this time.”


Comments

Use the comment form below to begin a discussion about this content.

Sign in to comment