Greater scrutiny drops Bahamas’ PPP scores

By NEIL HARTNELL

TRIBUNE Business Editor

nhartnell@tribunemedia.net

THE OPPOSITION’S leader yesterday asserted The Bahamas “has a long way to go” in making best possible use of public-private partnerships (PPP) as his party’s concerns dropped this nation’s score on the enabling climate for such investments.

Michael Pintard told Tribune Business that the Government has been using such structures “in a bad way”, including as “off-the-books loans” to keep spending and debt from adding to the fiscal deficit and appearing on the Government’s balance sheet, with an Inter-American Development Bank (IDB) sponsored index ranking The Bahamas 19th out of 26 western hemisphere nations on PPPs.

The Infrascope 2025-2026 report, which measures the investment climate and infrastructure available to facilitate PPPs in all those nations, said The Bahamas’ overall score had declined slightly compared to the prior assessment based - in part - on such concerns raised by Mr Pintard and other Free National Movement (FNM) members.

“The Bahamas’ overall score declined modestly from 33.1 in 2023-2024 to 32.1 in 2025-2026, reflecting increased parliamentary criticisms of PPPs and the unsuccessful Grand Bahama airport PPP, which was cancelled post-procurement after failing to reach financial close,” the Infrascope report said, while acknowledging that a new financing structure is being prepared for the latter project.

It added that improved transparency, disclosure and better fiscal risk management will be critical in ensuring The Bahamas properly selects, manages and extracts greater value for money from PPP deals. The study added that the revised PPP policy and accompanying documents unveiled by Michael Halkitis, minister of finance, in September 2026 for public consultation could “address long-standing preparation gaps” but have yet to be implemented.

Mr Halkitis did not respond to a Tribune Business message requesting comment before press time last night. Mr Pintard, meanwhile, argued that PPPs are “potentially a perfect tool” for financing and providing public infrastructure and services, but added that they have not been used in the correct way by the Davis administration.

“I would only say that The Bahamas has a long way to go in terms of the Government living up to PPPs, particularly given that when they came to power they met a policy in place which they did not abide by,” the Opposition leader told this newspaper, referring to the one established by the Minnis administration in 2018.

“They indicated they did not believe in going through the procurement process they met in place was doable, and even after they amended that law [Public Procurement Act 2023] they did not follow their own guidelines,” Mr Pintard added.

“We do not fundamentally have a problem - we believe PPPs are an extremely useful tool to allow governments to generate capital and attract expertise that the public sector cannot do on its own. But they have to be governed by very clear policies on how they are to be executed. We left in place a policy for this administration that we thought would be a wonderful guide, but they did not follow it.

“They continue to talk in this term about the modifications they intend to make when what needs to be modified more than anything is their behaviour with respect to PPPs. They are prepared to engage in a massive amount of direct awards with no explanation as to why they made that choice without going to competitive bidding.

Apart from roadworks projects on Eleuthera and Exuma by Bahamas Striping and its affiliates, valued at $180m and $62m, respectively, the $437m worth of PPPs identified in the 2026-2027 Budget include Cat Island Development Company’s $124m road upgrade and pipeline works on Cat Island, plus similar $52m and $19m works on San Salvador and at Mangrove Cay, Andros, by GDA Paving and Construction and Ambi's Paving.

However, Mr Pintard and the Opposition have consistently argued that these projects do not fit the model, or meet the test, of being true PPPs as their is no revenue stream - in the absence of these being toll roads - that would enable the private partner and its financing sources to be repaid and earn a return on their investment.

PPPs are typically designed to reduce the financial stress on cash-strapped governments by contracting the private sector to provide the funding, development and expertise to construct much-needed infrastructure or run public services.

The Government’s cash flow pressures are eased by requiring the private sector to finance the up-front capital costs, with the latter earning a return on investment - and paying back any lender - from the revenue streams generated by infrastructure assets they develop or services provided.

Given that this description does not match the PPPs cited by the Government, Mr Pintard and his party are arguing that they are really structured as off-the-books loans designed to keep spending and debt away from the deficit and government’s balance sheet.

The Government’s own Fiscal Strategy Report 2026 previously disclosed that some of these PPP liabilities have “crystallised” on the Government’s books as a debt that has to be repaid by Bahamian taxpayers.

The document, released alongside the 2026-2027 Budget, revealed that some $43.1m of the $140m PPP funding that the Africa Export-Import Bank has provided for road infrastructure upgrades on Eleuthera and Cat Island has now become a liability that the Government has to repay from the Public Treasury.

“The Government faces a potential contingent liability of $140m arising from financing arrangements with the African Export-Import Bank in respect of public-private partnership transactions with Bahamas Striping and Cat Island Infrastructure Company. At the time of preparation of this report, approximately $43.1m of this liability has crystallised in respect of these arrangements,” the Fiscal Strategy Report said.

Mr Pintard yesterday argued that Bahamian taxpayers, as well as future generations, do not know how much they are “on the hook” for when it comes to repaying debts allegedly incurred under these PPP deals because none of the terms or interest rates have been publicly disclosed or tabled in the House of Assembly.

He also called for greater disclosure over deals such as the Bahamas Grid Company arrangement, where transmission and distribution assets previously owned by the Bahamian people through Bahamas Power & Light (BPL) have been transferred to a private company for a minimum 25, and possibly 35, years.

“This government has a ways to go in terms of properly using PPPs,” Mr Pintard blasted. “The existing policy outlined potentially a perfect tool. They have been using these PPPs in a bad way. They have just not been open and transparent about the nature of these arrangements. We are left in the dark only to find out later these are debts or off-the-books loans we are engaged in and we are owing considerable amounts of finds.

“We are unsure if the Government is using PPPs to hide what the actual state of affairs is. We have a ways to go. It is not surprising that careful examination of how this government is managing the funds places them lower on any index.”

The Infrascope report makes clear the PPP criticism may be hitting home and starting to attract international attention. “Political scrutiny has increased,” it said. “Opposition figures have questioned the transparency of some recent PPP arrangements and their treatment of contingent liabilities. Greater disclosure and fiscal risk management will therefore be important as the PPP pipeline develops.”

However, giving credit to the Davis administration for the revised PPP policy now out for public consultation, the Infrascope report said this bid to “strengthen” the enabling environment “signals an effort to translate these ambitions into a more systematic programme, although implementation capacity remains a significant concern”.

It added that the failure to create a PPP steering committee and PPP operational unit, as envisaged by the Minnis administration policy in 2018, had left individual ministries in charge of their own such projects as opposed to “a fully operational” central unit.

“The Bahamas continues to face significant institutional and implementation gaps,” the Infrascope report said. “The absence of a fully operational PPP unit and weak inter-agency co-ordination leave it well behind the regional average on institutional capacity.

“Project preparation is also constrained by limited dedicated support and under-developed methodologies for assessing potential PPPs, including their economic and fiscal merits. Monitoring remains another important gap, with limited public reporting on PPP performance and no established process for ex-post evaluation.”


Comments

Use the comment form below to begin a discussion about this content.

Sign in to comment