NATIONAL Security Minister Myles LaRoda speaks during the Caribbean Anti-Gang, Transnational Organised Crime and Community Safety Conference-Workshop at the Paul Farquharson Conference Centre, Police Headquarters. Photo: Shawn Hann
By EARYEL BOWLEG
Tribune Staff Reporter
ebowleg@tribunemedia.net
NATIONAL Security Minister Myles LaRoda, whose ministry oversees the department that runs elections, said there is no law against campaign contributions in The Bahamas, but would not take a position on claims that the $30,000 Jonathan “Player” Gardiner carried on Election Day was for “campaign contributions and expenses”.
“I haven’t read it. I don’t have a position on that as yet,” Mr LaRoda said. He said he had not reviewed the latest court filings in the United States and could not speak to the specific allegations without the facts.
Gardiner’s lawyer, Susy Ribero-Ayala, made the claim in a reply filed in a New York federal court. She argued the cash was for campaign contributions and expenses as Gardiner travelled between islands with voters or campaign workers. The defence says none of the money was drug proceeds or a drug-related bribe, including about $5,000 in an envelope bearing a politician’s handwritten name.
Ms Ribero-Ayala wrote that the politician’s name and the timing must be weighed against the defence’s explanation and the way the cash was packaged, and that neither proves on its own that the envelope held a narcotics payment. The filing does not say whose campaign the money was meant to support or what the expenses were.
Prosecutors argue the timing points the other way. They say Gardiner carried the cash on Election Day itself rather than during the campaign. They describe the politician as a male incumbent MP who was re-elected that day. He has not been named or charged.
The defence also points to a Bank of The Bahamas receipt for a $20,000 withdrawal from Top Notch Builders Limited on May 11, the day before the election. Top Notch has received millions of dollars in government contracts under PLP administrations. Company documents list Gardiner as its president in 2016 and 2017.
The Bahamas has no campaign finance legislation, so political parties are not required to disclose who funds them, how much they receive or how they spend it.
The Parliamentary Elections Act does draw a line on Election Day. Giving or lending money to a voter to get them to vote, or not to vote, is bribery. Bribery is a corrupt practice punishable by up to two years in prison or a $2,000 fine, and a seven-year ban from voting or standing for election. The same Act says it is not an offence to provide transport for anyone to or from the poll, whether by land, sea or air.
On May 12, the plane carrying Gardiner from Marsh Harbour, Abaco, to Grand Bahama crashed off the Florida coast. Other passengers were PLP supporters travelling to Grand Bahama to vote. Eleven people were rescued. The others were allowed to leave, but Gardiner was taken into custody.
Gardiner, 58, was jailed in the US in 2008 for his role in an international drug conspiracy. He has pleaded not guilty in New York to conspiring to import cocaine, possessing firearms in furtherance of drug trafficking and conspiring to possess firearms. His trial is due to begin on March 1.
US authorities allege that the politician, referred to in court papers only as “Politician-1”, met an undercover DEA source and a drug pilot inside a Parliament building in October 2024 to discuss a cocaine shipment.
During the budget debate in June, Long Island MP Andre Rollins asked whether Gardiner had donated to any PLP campaigns. No PLP member rose to respond.
CARICOM’s election observers found no campaign finance legislation in The Bahamas. In their final report on the May 12 general election, released in August, they called for laws requiring parties to disclose their funding sources, limits on campaign spending and effective penalties for vote buying and misuse of state resources. The observers said stakeholders had alleged vote buying, but they did not find that it had happened.
They also recommended turning the Parliamentary Registration Department into an independent election management body. The department falls under the Ministry of National Security for administrative purposes, and Mr LaRoda agreed at the time that it should become independent.
Attorney General Wayne Munroe responded to the report by saying existing law already covers vote buying and treating.
Campaign finance reform has repeatedly been promised by the major political parties but never implemented. The Davis administration said it was not a priority during its first term.




Comments
Dawes 2 hours, 11 minutes ago
If it was a donation then let us know whose name was on the package
licks2 4 minutes ago
Why?? That een ya business sha!! That was private money until it was placed in a politician or poll worker's hand . . .and only for subverting the lawful election process!
Then if ya have information otherwise about for lawful election subversions. . .carry ya behind to the Police!!
I told yinna that yall was talking dumb crap. . .but yinna gone and run behind dumb Michael Pintard and talk a bunch of nonsense. . .now that it comes back to bite yinna hip yall want talk nanny!!
That's just what stupid talking normally does to ya. . .once it leaves ya mouth, you are bind to ya nonsense! Now playing like ya don't know nothing only serves to make yinna look stupid!!
Sign in to comment
OpenID