By RASHAD ROLLE
Tribune News Editor
rrolle@tribunemedia.net
A SUPREME Court judge has refused to let the only eyewitness who identified the gunmen in a 2020 New Providence murder testify anonymously, ruling that the witness’s statement that “I am in fear” did not show that the fear was reasonable.
Justice Dale Fitzpatrick denied the prosecution’s application for the witness, known only as “Alpha”, to give evidence with their identity hidden at the trial of Mauricio Webster. Webster is charged with the murder of Bradley Strachan, who was shot dead in the area of Rupert Dean Lane on December 23, 2020.
In a statement to police in February this year, Alpha said: “I am in fear. I only wish to give evidence as long as I remain anonymous.”
Justice Fitzpatrick said that statement did not disclose the basis for the witness’s fear. Prosecutors had offered no evidence to show it was objectively reasonable.
“It is not sufficient that harm is conceivable or that the witness is apprehensive,” Justice Fitzpatrick said in the ruling, dated November 13.
The judge accepted that witnessing a violent murder “could well explain” Alpha’s apprehension, and that a witness does not need to have received a direct threat before a reasonable fear can arise. But in the absence of any further evidence, Justice Fitzpatrick said, seeing the killing and knowing the accused men was not enough.
Prosecutors also argued that anonymity was in the interests of justice. The judge said this was not meaningfully pursued. The fact that a witness’s evidence may help prosecute a serious crime does not, by itself, justify hiding their identity.
Justice Fitzpatrick also refused a request for Alpha to testify by video link. The witness lives in Nassau and can come to court in person, the judge said.
The ruling describes Alpha as the only witness who identifies the shooters, making the testimony central to the prosecution’s case.
According to the ruling, Alpha told police that on the night of the killing, he or she saw two men known to them as “Bunwood” and “Little T” each firing a handgun at a man on Rupert Lane. Alpha said they recognised the men under a street light, and that neither was wearing a mask. Alpha later picked out Webster and Leonard Symonette from separate photo line-ups.
Symonette, who was charged alongside Webster in 2021, died from gunshot wounds to the neck, chest and right arm on April 11, 2025. The ruling records his death but does not address whether it had any bearing on the witness’s fear.
Webster had argued that the Criminal Evidence (Witness Anonymity) Act was unconstitutional because it denied him the right to face his accuser. Justice Fitzpatrick rejected that challenge, saying the law strikes a permissible balance between protecting vulnerable witnesses and the rights of the accused.
“The prevalence of retaliatory conduct and gun violence directed at witnesses is a troubling and recurring feature of the criminal court landscape here,” the judge said.
The ruling also sets out how anonymous testimony now works in the Supreme Court. The witness gives evidence by video from a separate room or building. The judge, jury and prosecutors see and hear the witness unaltered through monitors and noise-cancelling headphones. The accused and defence lawyers see the witness with their appearance obscured and voice distorted on a separate screen.
The decision came days after Justice Fitzpatrick allowed two witnesses, also known as “Alpha” and “Beta”, to testify anonymously at the trial of Clarington Bowleg, who is accused of a 2021 Harbour Island murder. Those witnesses said they feared for their lives.
Last December, Justice Fitzpatrick directed acquittals for two men charged in the 2017 killing of eight-year-old Eugene Woodside and Dennis Moss. That happened after prosecutors missed court deadlines to apply for their only eyewitness to testify anonymously, and then called no evidence. The prosecution has appealed.
Akire Nicolls appeared for the prosecution. Tonique Lewis represented Webster.




Commenting has been disabled for this item.